"The Independence Charade"
New York Times editorial
Nov. 5, 2005

Perhaps we should start at the bottom line. Don't vote for any candidates on the Independence Party row in Tuesday's elections. The Independence Party in New York City is not about independence. Just the opposite. It is about dependence on one man, Fred Newman, a former Marxist who is now a psychotherapist, and who has manipulated politicians, workers and voters in thinking that they are participating in a genuine political party.

As an investigative series on NY1 News reminded viewers this week, Dr. Newman's operation has a lot of the earmarks of a cult. Frank MacKay, the party’s state chairman, has little say over the local operations, and he has complained that city members never seem to challenge Dr. Newman’s views on politics “or anything else.” This is also the group that tolerated Lenora Fulani as a leader even after she refused to step back from her statement that Jews had to “function as mass murderers of people of color.” The state organization finally ousted Dr. Fulani from its executive committee in the face of boycott threats by state politicians. The Independence Party is one of the New York third parties that exist by endorsing candidates from other parties who like the idea of another spot on the ballot.

In the city, Mayor Michael Bloomberg, a Republican, is the most prominent candidate on the Independence Party line in Tuesday's election, and this is certainly not something he should be proud of. Nor should Democratic City Council members like John Liu of Queens, Erik Martin Dilan of Brooklyn or Maria del Carmen Arroyo in the Bronx.

The candidates and Dr. Newman are hoping that this extra line will confuse enough voters into thinking that one does not have to be a Democrat or a Republican on Election Day, but can somehow vote as an independent. No so. In New York City, the Independence Party simply isn't independent.